Shower Tile

[chrisray12]

I could have sworn this was answered before but I have been unable to find it with countless searches. Looking for replacement tiles for our shower. Has anyone found anything similar to the original. I broke about a dozen trying to get the rot out of the shower and want to replace those instead of retiling the whole shower with new tile. Plus I'd rather keep it as original as possible. Any insight or recommendations would be greatly appreciated. So far I am striking out with our local tile stores.